Providing Alcohol to an Alcoholic

Symptoms of a High Functioning Alcoholic

OPEC backs biggest oil cut since 2008 crisis

OPEC agreed on Thursday to cut oil output by an extra 1.5 million barrels per day (bpd) in the second quarter of 2020 to support prices that have been hit by the coronavirus outbreak, but made its action conditional on Russia and others joining in.

https://www.reuters.com/article/us-opec-meeting/opec-backs-biggest-oil-cut-since-2008-crisis-awaits-russia-idUSKBN20S0TT

Notice that this and pretty much every other news report you read never explains the thermodynamic implications of what they report, because they are ignorant of, and/or deny, the relationships between wealth creation, credit availability, and fossil energy consumption.

Oil producers today cut production by about 1.5%.

Why? Because demand for oil is falling and the world has limited storage capacity. Oil must be burned at about the same rate it is produced. If they don’t curtail production prices will fall below the cost of production and everyone will lose money, except of course shale oil producers who have always lost money.

Why is oil demand falling? Because the oil powered machines that produce and deliver almost all of the things we use and eat are slowing down, which means economic growth is slowing or possibly declining.

What happens if economic growth stops or declines? Our banking system becomes fragile because the design of our debt backed fractional reserve monetary system requires growth to function.

Put more simply, money and debt retain value, and credit remains plentiful, only in the presence of economic growth.

Why are credit and debt important? Because our standard of living depends on them. For example, today you can save 5% of the price of a house, get credit for 95% in the form of a mortgage, and immediately enjoy 100% of the house. Your mortgage, in turn, funds someone else’s retirement portfolio. Without plentiful credit, most people will not enjoy their own home, or car, or iPhone, and most people will not be able to retire.

I explained the importance of growth and why we can’t have it forever in more detail here.

How have our leaders responded? Canada announced an emergency interest rate cut yesterday in the hope of stimulating economic growth. Our prime minister is planning to spend more printed money to stimulate growth.

Will it work? Does providing alcohol to an alcoholic work? Yes, for a while, unless he’s already too drunk, but doing so makes his bottom more painful.

How do you know when an alcoholic is too drunk? You offer him free liquor and he does not drink.

How do you know when an alcoholic has not yet bottomed out? He kills his hangover the next day with a drink.

How do you know when it’s too late to save an alcoholic? He dies from an overdose.

How do you know when an alcoholic is clean? He decides to promote and vote for a birth lottery.

<Edit Mar 8>

I’m going to go out on a limb and say the correction has begun that those of us with defective denial genes have anticipated since the rocket scientists that lead us “fixed” the too much debt crisis in 2008 with more debt. They’ll try again this time but I suspect the alcoholic is too drunk to drink. I don’t know if the drunk will respond if they try extreme measures like intravenous white lightning. Assuming he doesn’t, my guess is 20-50% of paper wealth will vaporize in this step down. There are more steps to follow in coming years until the alcoholic bottoms out when his preferred drink, oil, is gone. There’d be much less pain for all if he’d sober up now.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

138 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

David
David
Reply to  Rob Mielcarski
April 20, 2020 5:27 pm

Excellent point! We humans are meaning-making-machines. We love to make up a story so we can feel secure because we “understand”. Whether or not the story is actually true does not seem to matter to most of us.

X
X
April 17, 2020 8:30 am

“The massive slump on the stock markets and the flight to safe investments is a reaction to these shocks, but may trigger further shocks and intensify the downward dynamic in the real economy. The extent of these shocks depends heavily on expectations and thus on psychological factors. Economic policy measures must be tailored and targeted to these specificities. The timing and communication of the measures are crucial. The most important goal is to secure the public’s trust so that the health crisis does not turn into a systemic economic crisis that affects the labor market, banks, and financial markets, thus further weakening domestic demand.”

https://www.ifo.de/en/themen/coronavirus

MickN
MickN
Reply to  Rob Mielcarski
April 13, 2020 12:52 am

We will miss him. Our old friend Moral Hazard, who had been on life support since 2008, finally gave up the ghost in April 2020. Having lived a long and useful life he was finally taken from us by Covid19 and the comorbidities of the accumulated financial shenanigans of the last few decades.
Let her rip you bankers, traders, hedgies – anything goes from here on in as long as it’s big enough. Don’t worry though Moral Hazards little brother, Moral Hazard for the not so rich and downright poor, is still in robust health and promises he will be with us until the very end.

https://www.msn.com/en-gb/money/other/seen-everywhere-in-last-us-crisis-moral-hazard-is-nowhere-in-this-one/ar-BB12vT5K?ocid=spartanntp

zeeee censor
zeeee censor
Reply to  Rob Mielcarski
April 10, 2020 5:30 pm

Excellent stuff, thanks for posting.

Ian Graham
Ian Graham
Reply to  Rob Mielcarski
April 7, 2020 6:51 pm

how do you mean he ‘misled’ listeners on Rogan? do yo have the link and min: for that? thanks

Ian Graham
Ian Graham
April 4, 2020 3:04 pm

Some quotes and links of late, many from Panopticon’s Climate and Economy blog:
“Otherwise we run the risk of complete economic chaos as supplies shrink and shortages emerge, with widespread unemployment and poverty, with associated social and political unrest.” ( https://qz.com/india/1830822/coronavirus-may-push-indias-struggling-economy-off-the-cliff/)
And Timothy Lenton: The coronavirus pandemic has reshaped the way we live, work, and interact in a matter of weeks. It has also shown that governments are able—and in many cases are expected—to take swift, significant action on crises. “Under these extraordinary circumstances, there can be quite decisive action from governance and policy that changes the way we’re all living day to day,” Lenton said. “It is possible to change large-scale patterns of human behavior, pretty quickly.”
the climate crisis cannot be solved incrementally, Lenton said, because it’s
taken too long to spur action: Many warming-related changes are already
underway. Global greenhouse gas emissions must be dramatically reduced and
eventually eliminated. “If we’re going to avoid the worst of bad climate
tipping points, then we’re going to need to find some positive tipping points
in society and ourselves to transform the way we live—in a generation”
Reported in https://newrepublic.com/article/157078/climate-crisis-will-just-shockingly-abrupt

MickN
MickN
Reply to  Rob Mielcarski
March 27, 2020 3:56 am

What do you make of this Rob-from half a million dead to less than 20000. Perhaps the Oxford report was more accurate?
https://www.newscientist.com/article/2238578-uk-has-enough-intensive-care-units-for-coronavirus-expert-predicts/

MickN
MickN
Reply to  Rob Mielcarski
March 27, 2020 3:45 pm

Yep-I don’t know either. There are some big time academic reputations on the line here. Time, as always, will tell – if we’re still here when the telling is told.

X
X
March 24, 2020 12:36 am

An unprecedented effort! We’re fighting the apocalyptic evil! Fed announces unlimited bond purchases in unprecedented move aimed at preventing an economic depression. Thanks to Fed, money will surely keep on flowing to companies, households and cities (not only in the USA; of course the rest of the world will do the same and then money just keeps on flowing from heaven.)
https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2020/03/23/fed-unlimited-credit-coronavirus/

X
X
March 22, 2020 3:03 am

So EU has decided to print much more money and give a fistful of euros to Italy. But is there any difference to what the U.S.A is doing? If everyone does it, no country will go Weimar or Zimbabwe. Helicopter money will be the new manna from heaven. What could possibly go wrong? Cheers!