Thank you to Gaia for contributing this essay on her experience with growing coffee in Australia, and my apologies for the delay in posting. I have been procrastinating everything in my life of late, I’m sorry.
When I think about end of growth implications, and the coming scarcity of things we now take for granted, coffee is at the top of my list of things I will miss. My favorite moment of every day is the first sip of the triple espresso Americano I make every morning.
Preptip:
We cannot grow coffee here in Canada and someday I will probably have to make do without. As a hedge against inflation, and as a buffer for the early days when supply will likely be intermittent or unaffordable, I stock a fair amount of coffee.
I have learned that unopened roasted beans taste fine well past their best-by date. I have not yet done enough tests to know how much past the best-by date is ok, but I currently assume at least 2 years.
I consume 50 g per day which is 1 Kg every 20 days. When scarcity arrives, I will reduce my consumption in half to double the duration, and then halve it again if necessary. I stock about 20 Kg of roasted beans, plus 10 Kg of canned ground coffee which has a longer shelf-life, plus 6 Kg of instant coffee which has an infinite shelf-life.
When my preferred source of caffeine is no longer available, I will switch to black tea, which I also stock in large quantities because it has an excellent shelf-life, and is still very inexpensive.
One of my projects this year at the farm I assist is to construct a shipping container size dehydrator which we plan to use initially for making tea from black current leaves. Apparently it’s a tasty healthy tea, but alas has no caffeine.
As the end of growth approaches we know there will be price inflation for necessities. The price of all food has increased a lot in Canada over the last few years, but coffee stands out as one of the worst. I buy the cheapest espresso beans available in my community and the price has almost doubled over the last 4 years from $14/Kg in 2021 to $22/Kg today.
Why are coffee prices increasing?
Grok: Coffee prices are increasing due to a combination of environmental, economic, and geopolitical factors affecting global supply and demand. Severe weather events, particularly in major coffee-producing countries like Brazil and Vietnam, have significantly reduced crop yields. Brazil, the world’s largest coffee producer, has faced droughts, frosts, and excessive rains, leading to lower arabica bean production. Similarly, Vietnam, a key supplier of robusta beans, has experienced droughts followed by flooding, cutting output. These disruptions have tightened global coffee supplies, with some estimates suggesting deficits for multiple consecutive years.
Rising global demand is also a factor, as coffee consumption grows in markets like China and India, alongside steady demand in traditional markets like the U.S. and Europe. This imbalance between shrinking supply and growing demand has driven wholesale prices up, with arabica beans surpassing $4 per pound in early 2025, a level not seen in decades.
I’m sure printing trillions of dollars to force a little more growth from lethargic energy supplies, while using an engineered virus as an excuse, probably also has something to do with the price increases.
Also, after reading Gaia’s essay, it’s clear there is a lot of human and fossil energy required to produce coffee, which no doubt has also contributed to the price increase.
Now over to Gaia…
Some days I am just so disheartened by what is happening on our planet on all fronts, but yet we must bear it and bear witness to the fullness of what we as a species have wrought. That is taking more courage than I ever believed I could have, but yet I must try and it certainly is a comfort to have friends on your site who are sharing similarly. I am finding great joy in communing with nature, especially through tending food plants and feeling so much gratitude for their sustenance for body and spirit. I have been wanting to share snapshots in picture and words of my experience on the land to add to the collective wonder and appreciation of so many others’ homesteading stories and images, including your fulfilling season at the farm. I think I can manage in bite-sized snippets, and if a picture can tell a thousand words, then I should be out of business sooner or later!
I think you Rob are the number one coffee addict that I know and definitely the most prepared for when the SHTF. I think you could open SHTF Cafe at the End of the World, it only needs one table and chair just for you! In honour of your habit, these are the very first photos I will share relating to our property and lifestyle. You may refer back to the post where I described in some detail (and you thought it was TMI until I clarified a very critical point!) how I successfully processed coffee from bush to bean–for possibly the first and last time as it took quite a bit of effort for not very many cups of the finished drink, which I don’t even imbibe! I do drink decaf but there is no feasible home method for that, unfortunately. I cannot say how my single estate grown coffee tastes, but it did smell as heavenly as anything when I was roasting the beans, so at least that is something.

The photo does not depict the intoxicatingly sweet fragrance from these flowers, just divine! This particular plant is a prostrate form and the flowers are layered on long branches, very attractive.

Here is the same plant about nine months later, with the berries finally ripe. Our property is located in highland tropics and the cooler climate which slows ripening of the fruit is supposed to produce a more complex flavour profile. I enjoy eating some of the red berries, the scant pulp has an appreciable sweetness, somewhat caramel-like, and the red skins which are loaded with antioxidants taste a bit like raw green beans, not unpleasant at all.

It took about 15 minutes to pick this bowl of berries, not too onerous as one just strips the branch from top to bottom. Squeezing the berries to pop out the beans, usually 2 per berry, sometimes 3, takes a bit more time and I found it best to do it underwater otherwise the beans have a tendency to fly everywhere. Then you have to soak the beans for 24-48 hours to ferment off the slimy pulp surrounding them (this is what makes them slippery suckers that shoot in every direction).
I didn’t take a photo of the drying and hulling process, which is the next step. I placed the beans in a mesh bag and sundried them for about a day. You know when it’s dried when the outer parchment-like husk starts to crack a bit along the middle of the bean. Removing this rather hard covering is the most time-consuming and tricky part of the operation. I looked online for advice and it seems like putting the beans in a food processor that has plastic blades (some models have plastic blades for stirring function, I happen to have this) which won’t pulverise the beans is the best solution if you don’t want to try to remove the parchment layer by hand. There will always be some beans to be hand hulled, usually they rub off in 2 halves. The plastic blades agitate the beans enough to slough off the dried parchment hull on most of the beans, but you have to do this in small batches. Then you still have to somehow separate the beans from the removed hulls and the best method is winnowing, tossing the beans and hulls up and down on a tray in a current of air (on a windy day) and the air blows the hulls away whilst the heavier beans drop back down into the tray.
Finally, you will have achieved getting green coffee beans that are ready for roasting. You can do this on the stovetop, constantly shaking and stirring the pot, or in an oven, also turning the beans, but I found the easiest way is to use my hand-crank popcorn maker which is basically a pot with a metal wire stirrer on the bottom that you can keep turning whilst on the burner (this is an essential device if popcorn is your thing, and a very useful one in any case because you can toast all manner of nuts and seeds–and now coffee beans!) This took about 8 minutes of cranking (and heating) but so worth it as the smell of roasting coffee is as heavenly as the smell of the flowers from whence they originated. I was really quite chuffed when I got to this stage just for that irresistible aroma which was actually emanating from my own beans!

Viola! As you can see, I think I roasted them to an espresso strength. At long last, you have in your hand the pitifully meager result of all the work I have tried to describe in painstaking detail. In total, I think I processed in my first batch enough coffee for one person drinking one cup for about a week or less. But that’s not the point, which was really to experience all the labour involved if one had to do this by hand so we can appreciate all the more how mechanisation (and exploited labour) are the reason why we have so much for not much effort on our part other than probably the final grinding and boiling water. It highlighted for me the impossibility of being able to self produce (even if one lived in the right climate) even a fraction of the foodstuffs we take for granted daily if we were to use our own labour. In this example, I still had to use some modern devices, and certainly fossil fuels made possible the final brewing, which is the whole point of the whole endeavour. Very sobering indeed, rather than stimulating as from caffeine.
Well, it looks like it still takes Gaia 1000s of words to describe anything even when accompanied by pictures! I hope you all enjoyed this first pictorial installment of Gaia’s garden and kitchen. For all you coffee lovers out there, enjoy what you have whilst you can! This documentary has probably prompted Rob to invest in even more quantity of coffee, not a bad idea really. No doubt it will be a trading commodity in our near future.
Namaste everyone.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Clear unpleasant evidence yet silence means MORT.
https://www.coffeeandcovid.com/p/safe-but-risky-saturday-may-3-2025
LikeLike
A clever way on bringing out the data by comparing vax shots and outcomes not using unvaxxed data.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Crazy Eddy had me laughing today. “It’s Pro Wrestling Day here in Australia – otherwise known as election day” Ambushed by Barnyard Animals
Never know what’s fact or fiction with Eddy, but it doesn’t matter as long as its entertaining. Wish I had written it. Oh, how I really hate him.😂
LikeLiked by 1 person
HHH says to expect lower interest rates and QE. In other threads he has argued QE does not cause inflation. I disagree. I think QE causes inflation because it enables higher government deficits.
My prediction is assuming no crash we will experience higher inflation.
I also predict more war because leaders can do nothing about falling standards of living so if they want to stay in power their only option is to redirect their citizen’s anger to other tribes.
Let’s see what happens.
https://peakoilbarrel.com/us-february-oil-production-marginally-higher/#comment-788634
LikeLike
Very interesting. Thank you.
I don’t understand money very well. But, let me try asking my naïve questions…
Isn’t QE like a way to put money out of the system by postponing the day where it comes back to haunt you (maybe indefinitely)?
Also, aren’t low interest rates, lowering the speed at which total money expands?
Wouldn’t negative interest rates, enable the diminution of the money volume?
(If one wants to keep the current system), in addition to negative interest rates, which applies only to newly created debt, isn’t what’s needed a renogociation of existing debts: diminution of existing rates and postponing of payments?
Also, there is a dissimetry in the current system that seems unfair (because I don’t like centralization of power :), when, as an personal investor, you lend money, you don’t have the money available. If my understanding is correct, that’s different with banks. So, in addition, shouldn’t the banks (all of them, even the central one) lose that privilege?
Of course, all these changes can’t be done overnight, as they might crash the existing system. Too risky. Maybe it could be progressively driven.
I look at the monetary system, and it feels like a gigantic leash forcing all the living to run on threadmill (the mega-machine) and send money back to “the masters”. But, the threadmill is rusting, and the living beings don’t have much juice left. So, one way or another it’s coming to an end. Some of “the masters” are giving some room to the leash in an attempt to not lose their control.
Just, an analogy. Not to be taken too seriously.
By the way, to me, the shape money takes form (bank notes, credit cards, digital, bitcoin…), doesn’t matter as much to me (even if things such as the future intermittence of electricity has to be taken into account) as the values, properties and system it implements.
Currently it seems we have a loosely centralized (many banks can create money), exclusive (alternatives are forbidden), expansion oriented system, where the speed of expansion can be adjusted centrally (the central bank makes the choices of the length of the leash, risking it to either break or entangle if it doesn’t listen to reality).
Is this what the Ukraine war enables for Russia? Did Russia own a lot of dollar denominated debt it couldn’t pay back, unless maybe it exclusively sold all of its assets (oil, land) to the US?
Thanks.
LikeLike
But, at this point of reaching the limits, government deficit is the only way to create new money, isn’t it? And new money is needed to repay the loans previously contracted by selling something to the american government to get dollars.
Am I understanding correctly?
LikeLike
Yes, I think you understand.
Government deficits stop the system from collapsing by creating the new money required to service debt. Limits to growth prevent real wealth growing as fast as the government deficit so we get inflation. At some point the commercial banks become unwilling to loan to the government because of the risk and then QE is replaced with real money printing and we get hyperinflation. Or the government accepts reality and we get a deflationary collapse.
LikeLike
Thank you.
LikeLike
More from HHH on the same thread.
LikeLike
Yes, but I guess China is powerful enough to default and switch to a new system (at the cost of a war). It is a matter of balance of powers.
That would be the path of competition.
Or, it is still theoretically possible to change the rules of the system, so that loans need not be repaid in their entirety.
Or just hand out money at negative interest rate so that it gets easier to repay debt.
But then, of course, the system would lose its ability to pump of material wealth towards the American government.
That would be the path of dialogue and cooperation.
Smart people would choose cooperation because the cost of war would exceed the cost of negociating the debt.
Because, my guess is, when in degrowth/collapse, war hardly pays. (OK you win the war, but the spoils are so few, that you lose anyway. And your credibility is over as a fair player.)
But then there are the questions of the speed of collapse, and maybe the scale of the greed, insanity and idiocy? of some people in position of power. Especially, if they are in a position to play for themselves against every body else. High treachery.
If I am understanding well… Pretty complex.
LikeLiked by 1 person
https://peakoilbarrel.com/open-thread-non-petroleum-may-3-2025/#comment-788669
LikeLike
Told like that, it sounds like the story of the massive european grid with renewables: a complex system becoming more and more brittle and unpredictably subject to catastrophic failure.
Maybe?, these failures will not be terminal, but stress tests that gradually lead to the transformation of the global monetary system into a more byzantine patchwork of various systems, with delays and firewalls.
Less efficient but more robust. (Olivier Hamant salient idea had a big impact on me 🙂
In any case, every thing happens at the same time. 2025 is really the year of waking up.
So many people that I talk to these days, finally let their true self go through, express their true emotions, their true desires. I love to talk through the shells, even though, I myself, have gotten used to my protective layers of social masks.
LikeLiked by 1 person
‘It’ depends upon the ‘type of QE’?
“Importantly for our disaggregated quantity equation, credit creation can be disaggregated, as we can obtain and analyse information about who obtains loans and what use they are put to. Sectoral loan data provide us with information about the direction of purchasing power – something deposit aggregates cannot tell us. By institutional analysis and the use of such disaggregated credit data it can be determined, at least approximately, what share of purchasing power is primarily spent on ‘real’ transactions that are part of GDP and which part is primarily used for financial transactions. Further, transactions contributing to GDP can be divided into ‘productive’ ones that have a lower risk, as they generate income streams to service them (they can thus be referred to as sustainable or productive), and those that do not increase productivity or the stock of goods and services. Data availability is dependent on central bank publication of such data. The identification of transactions that are part of GDP and those that are not is more straight-forward, simply following the NIA rules.”
http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/339271/1/Werner_IRFA_QTC_2012.pdf
LikeLike
I really like Tim Watkins newest essay. (h/t crazy eddy). The world ended in 1999
I’ve tried to write about how incredibly lame the world got towards the end of the 20th century. It always ends up as a bitch fest about how wack music and tv/movies have become. Look at the top radio songs from back then and it’s dominated by no talent hacks like Backstreet Boys, Britney Spears, NSYNC, J Lo, Ja Rule, Ludacris, Nelly.
Television shows back in the day were extremely lucky if they made it 10 seasons (MASH, Cheers, Frasier… there were a few, but for the most part, even the good ones were canceled after a few years to make room for new ideas). Late 90’s/early 00’s is when it all changes. Two important factors that killed the old tv formula…. this new concept called branding as well as the beginning craze of reality and game shows. Shitty primetime shows like American Idol, Survivor, and The Bachelor are pushing 25 seasons!
See, all I do is bitch when try to talk about it😊. Tim did a great job connecting some of these dots.
LikeLike
Something definitely changed for the worse.
I’m sitting here adding nicer artwork to my library of music albums from the 60’s and 70’s while I’m watching the Peter Gunn TV series (1958-1961) out the corner of my eye for the second time.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Nice. Love the old black and white classics. Lately I’ve been into Sherlock Holmes movies from the ’40s. The actor playing Holmes is good, but Watson steals the show with his comedic skills.
The is my favorite one so far.
LikeLike
That brings back good memories. I have a collection of Sherlock Holmes radio plays from 1940-1946 starring Basil Rathbone & Nigel Bruce that I listened to years ago.
LikeLiked by 1 person
OMG, occultist Thomas Sheridan has been saying for several years now that time stopped in 2000. He feels reality is reconverging, and that we’ve all been in some sort of dream state since 9/11. It’s quite a metaphorical interpretation of a very real situation unfolding.
I really enjoy Watkin’s writing, and I know he reads here off and on. Hi Tim!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thomas did a whole series of videos on his idea called Wave Function Collapse. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=taYjKwqFi4w
LikeLike
The AfD, which Elon Musk supported a few months ago, was labelled as extremist by the German Domestic Intelligence Agency.
https://www.npr.org/2025/05/02/g-s1-64037/afd-germany-extremist-alternative
LikeLike
All I know about the AfD is one lengthy interview I watched with its leader. Definitely not extremist. I’d vote for them if they were on offer here.
LikeLike
Maybe Alice Weidel herself isn’t an extremist, but there certainly are extremists within the AfD. The video goes into more detail.
LikeLike
Who told you they were extremists? Oh extremists also known as the thought police.
Please show us your research and examples of their nazi behaviour.
Please remember that most msm is propaganda.
Do you pay attention to the news items on peak oil msm or hideway’s or HHH’s in depth analysis and well reasoned responses?
I think we face extremism in thought but mostly generated on the left. That doesn’t mean the right don’t have to keep themselves in check.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The video gives a few examples.
Here is another example. The AfD’s Secret Plan to Deport Millions From Germany
https://www.thenation.com/article/world/germany-afd-secret-meeting-deportation/
For other examples of extremism in the AfD, look at Björn Höcke, chairman of AfD in Thuringia. On top of all of this, the AfD also denies climate change as well.
NPR is mainstream media, but the video is not what I would call “mainstream media” (The video itself comes from a socialist perspective). And, Yes, I have read Hideaway’s and many of HHH’s analyses. Our leaders, unable or unwilling to admit that the economy is running into limits to growth, are looking for scapegoats.
There are some left-wing extremists but they don’t have much political power at the moment.
LikeLike
firstly Germany’s government has been actively supporting nazis in Ukraine so that means that there is no difference there.
secondly deporting masses of people that have come into the country through planned disruption by current governments doesn’t make it extreme. I know Germany well and the people are slowly getting more pissed off about the loss of their cultural identity and how their politicians are screwing them over.
I think climate change is of zero concern (nothing can or will be done we just ride it out) does that make me a fascist or just a realist.
Practically the western world is circling the toilet now because the left extreme positions have been in the drivers seat (if the right had been in control we would just be circling it in the other direction).
I personally know Germans who think that the AFD is the only party listening to them. I am not saying they have answers more than anyone else but dialogue would be better than tar and feathering.
LikeLike
The people in power in the West for past 40 years have mostly been neoliberal globalists, not genuine leftists.
LikeLike
Please don’t fall for this nonsense – Correctiv is a left wing propaganda media and the plans from the secret meeting are disproven. You may use a translator to do some deeper research:
https://www.danisch.de/blog/2024/08/07/kritik-an-correctiv-was-hat-die-bundesregierung-mit-correctiv-zu-tun/
(Mr Danisch is a critical blogger with considerable reach, and among other topics, he exposes the involvement of the German government, secret services and NGOs in their efforts to install a socialistic surveillance state).
The AfD is not right wing extremist, it’s just the most conservative party in Germany, representing values that the CDU represented 25 years ago. But for a socialist government, everything that does not correspond to their opinion is right-wing extremist.
See this year’s election: 23% of the people voted for AfD (second most result), but since their views are not wanted, they are simply ignored by all other parties when forming a coalition. They call it “Brandmauer” (fire wall) – quite democratic, isn’t it?
80% of Germans want socialism again and we are on the verge of establishing GDR 2.0…
LikeLike
Stellar is a victim of german msm.
Saludos
el mar
LikeLike
Most read articles 2024: March-“Correctiv” refutes itself in court
The revelations by the “Correctiv” research team have been keeping the country on edge for two months now. This week, however, “Correctiv” confirmed in court that none of the revelations were based on facts. This was the most-read “Cicero” article of March.
https://www.cicero.de/innenpolitik/meistgelesene-artikel-2024-marz-correctiv-widerlegt-sich-vor-gericht-selbst
LikeLike
Excellent interview with Brian Berletic on what the US is really doing by pretending to be a mediator in the war it is leading against Russia.
LikeLike
Hi Gaïa gardener,
I was wondering. Did you ever host woofers (or similar) at your place?
Best.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi Charles. We have started hosting woofers at our place and have had very good experiences so far. We are not officially listed but have met them through word of mouth via friends who are.
LikeLike
Nice to hear. That’s great.
LikeLike
Gotta love them Houthis. Scared an F16 off the deck of a US aircraft carrier last week. Dropped a missile on Ben Gurion airport today. They stop when US/Israel stops genociding Gaza citizens.
LikeLiked by 2 people
I fear that we will have a war in the Middle East/Iran within a month or so. We might avoid Nuke WW3 if the U.S. or Israel don’t use them and if China and Russia don’t get involved. I think that might just add a little chaos to everyone’s economic predictions (and maybe collapse the whole system?). And what happens in Ukraine? Do Europeans try to help Ukraine? How, would Russia respond (I think Putin has the upper hand and is tired of dealing with the idiots (U.S.)).
John Mearsheimer with Glenn Diesen and Alexander Mercouris had an interesting discussion the other day. Mearsheimer thinks Trump is a complete idiot who knows nothing and is all bravado. Bad feeling that Trump will get the U.S. involved in a losing war in Iran and maybe Ukraine too. Not going to work out well – in fact maybe we won’t have any economics left to talk about.
AJ
LikeLike
It looks like an Iran war soon to me too. It’s impossible to predict who gets involved and the outcome but the worst case is really bad. The US does not want a peace deal with Iran, it wants regime change and subservience.
LikeLiked by 1 person
LikeLike
u/Urshilikai posted
LikeLiked by 3 people
Stellar that all rings so true for me as well! I’ve also been using it to help with some health issues that no doctor had been able to resolve. I tried SSRIs, but they made things worse. Then I worked with AI and realised I needed B12. Since starting B12, I’ve been doing so much better.
In the book The Way Home: Tales from a Life Without Technology by Mark Boyle, he spoke with older Irish people about which technological invention most disrupted their social lives. Surprisingly, it turned out to be the thermos. Mark hadn’t expected that at all. The thermos meant people no longer gathered around a fire to make tea together at break time.
LikeLiked by 3 people
I was wondering if you were ok monk. Glad you found something that’s helping.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m doing good! I have a very stressful job and this year has been the busiest ever. I am also struggling with unexplained infertility – but really I think it is the job stress and being overweight that is the problem. My thyroid function isn’t great so I am trying to improve my health. I don’t do well on pharmaceuticals so trying to improve things the natural way with food, exercise and stress management
LikeLiked by 2 people
Hey Monk,
my partner has thyroid issues. If you really want to get a handle on the intricacies of thyroid hormone cascades I would recommend.
https://thyroidpharmacist.com/
Listen to the podcasts and you will get info on what to test for and all of the non pharma routes to take in order to deal with it.
nikoB
LikeLiked by 2 people
OK many thanks for that! I am doing a lot of research on it. Both my mum and her mum had thyroid problems. It’s a bit scary. And it is such a common problem that doesn’t get treated very thoroughly by family doctors
LikeLike
Hey from my brief look at the website, this is very similar to the work that I am doing and the things I have uncovered through my research 🙂 hopefully I am on the right track
LikeLike
good to hear
LikeLike
Monk wrote, “Surprisingly, it turned out to be the thermos.”
Years ago I was talking with an old Florida citrus grower and said air conditioning
must have brought really big changes, as it did elsewhere in the South(USA).
He agreed and said AC was big, but before that, an even bigger change was
wire mesh window screens.
No more shared, smoky fires to keep the skeeters at bay.
Thinking about it, in my childhood there were many screened picnic shelters in parks, at schools, and other useful locations. Few of these are still around, as everybody wants AC.
Our Library has a meeting room with heat and AC, and no windows. There is a nice picnic table outside for when the weather is pleasant.
Thanks and good health, Weogo
LikeLiked by 2 people
Nice find Stellar.
I know no one in real life that I can discuss what I really think. Some topics like covid make people angry. I get why no one want to discuss overshoot. The avoidance of covid reality remains a mystery. It was a totally avoidable crime made worse by incompetence and then ass covering. 20+ million killed is a big deal. No one cares about holding anyone accountable, not even to prevent a recurrence.
LikeLiked by 2 people
The West should be the last to worry about peak oil , you will always have your sunni arab feudal Persian Gulf slave dogs by your side . The arab middle east post 9/11 is an american military colony as intented .
LikeLike
If you are suggesting the west will be immune to energy depletion problems while 7 billion “others” collapse I think you’re wrong. The world is so complex and so interconnected now that we’ll more or less go down in unison.
LikeLiked by 4 people
Dr. Tim Morgan took a break to reflect on reality and came back focused on denial.
There are many great minds sniffing around Dr. Ajit Varki’s MORT without being aware it.
LikeLiked by 4 people
Tried to reply to a comment there but it’s still awaiting moderation. Either Dr Tim doesn’t like my fire bullshit or maybe all comments have to be approved and he just hasn’t got around to it yet.
________________________________________________
“… would be good to start talking about solutions, rather than relentlessly reviewing the problem… The 2 biggest questions of our times are what sort of society will allow us to live well within the boundaries of nature, and how can we build it.” – Zoltan
Very simple answer if we really are actually talking about living within the boundaries of nature. The sort of society that will allow that is one where no single species stands out from the pack (in other words, where no single species is capable of creating a self-induced mass extinction).
Fire doesn’t belong in the equation for living within the boundaries of nature. The benefits/advantages gained from the long-term use of it (a million years) eventually culminated with Sapiens being injected with the nightmare of full consciousness around 100-200kya. No other species has ever been near this level of consciousness. Why? Because no other species has harnessed fire.
The main requirement of full consciousness – to create meaning out of nothing so that the bleakness of it all can be hidden and denied, to ensure that your species will continue on in the history books – is the very same thing that pushes you further away from living within the boundaries of nature.
Fire leads to full consciousness… which then leads to domestication, agriculture, and mining… which then leads to fossil energy… which then leads to a speedy self-induced mass extinction. No species that conquers fire can ever fit in with the web of life. At certain stages it might appear possible, but it’s just an illusion. Let it play out and it will always end up miserably for the rest of life and the planet.
The easiest solution is to remove the fire users. Hence the quick mass extinction that comes guaranteed when you start playing with fossil fuels… because call it a hunch, but I dont think Sapiens will ever voluntarily stop using fire.😉
Sapiens make up only 0.01% of the biomass weight on this planet… yet we’ve created more technomass (man-made shit) than the total weight of all biomass! Fire is responsible for this godlike level of separation & superiority.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Here are a few terms that might be helpful for your story.
Humans use fossil energy to grow their food which makes them a unique heterotroph. What should we call humans?
What is an exosomatic heterotroph?
Notice how I had to know the answer to get the answer from Grok.
LikeLiked by 3 people
Thanks for the info. Yes, very helpful in selling my story if I can incorporate some of this stuff into it.
You sent me on a mad scramble to find where I had heard these words before. Scanned a few old Michael Dowd and Sid Smith videos. Found it on this Sid clip below. But I was wrong. It wasn’t autotrophs and heterotrophs… it was omnivores and detritivores.
Detritivore – an organism that sustains itself by consuming organic waste material from decomposing dead plants or animals.
Sid talks about William Catton’s brilliant observation at the 20:45 to 22:06 mark (should be queued up)
LikeLiked by 1 person
I remember that talk with Sid Smith. He’s very good.
LikeLike
Brandon Young is taking full advantage of the fact that his nemesis (Hideaway) is on vacation.
LOL, I get in a goofy mood sometimes and I’ll start trolling certain blogsites. Even when I’m trying to be funny with the most hopium filled bullshit I can think of… I still can’t come close to anything as good as Brandon.😊
LikeLiked by 1 person
Brandon is proof that MORT is true.
LikeLiked by 1 person
LikeLiked by 2 people
Trump’s strongest supporters are turning on him.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I wonder if Trump is starting to show signs of dementia? Not everyone in cognitive decline is like Biden was for the last few years. Trump being a narcissist seems also to have lost some of the control he had in the first term; he seems much more “stream of consciousness” unfiltered (i.e. stupid shit). And he is going on 79 and is not physically fit, both harbingers for cognitive decline. ??
AJ
LikeLiked by 1 person
Comparing us at the same younger age I’m probably a lot smarter than Trump yet I’m pretty sure I would not be competent to hold a complex job at 79.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I have researched dementia quite a bit since both my parents died with severe dementia (you don’t actually die from severe dementia but from the brain finally not being able to control breathing/heart or the immune system collapse).
Genetics accounts for only about 2 – 3% of dementia. Most of dementia is the result of bad lifestyle choices that have adverse affects on the brain over time. High simple carb diet, alcohol, smoking, sedentary lifestyle, low blood level of vit D and B vitamins, not enough good fats (fish), high levels of metabolic dysfunction (prediabetes, diabetes, chronic inflammation).
There are those rare individuals that got all the diet/lifestyle choices right, have great genetics and an interesting life that never show signs of dementia. You could be that one Rob!
Ezekiel Emanuel (Rahm Emanuel’s brother) is an oncologist and wrote an essay a few years ago that he only wanted to live to 75 and would refuse medical interventions after that. His rational, informed by his having been a practicing physician, was that beyond 75 the quality of life deteriorates rapidly for most people. I agree and don’t want to live beyond 75 either. Hell would be descending into dementia and being a vegetable (more than I am now). So, I would like to make it to 75 with health and my brain intact and then consider suicide. Of course Trump might upend everything and were all dead a few weeks after the nukes fly.
AJ
LikeLiked by 2 people
If you can avoid seriousness chronic illness and accidents (like falling off ladders) I think you can have great quality of life beyond 75. Have seen several in my family live very well into late 80s
LikeLike
Dementia is normal for humans. The longer we live more dementia.According to Jarle Breivik, expanding on a concept by former BMJ editor Richard Smith, there are essentially four ways to die:
Breivik points out that medicine often doesn’t eliminate death but shifts it: when we treat or prevent one cause (like heart disease), we tend to increase the likelihood of dying from another, such as cancer or dementia.
LikeLike
This Deranged Ghoul is somehow in the U.S. House of representatives.
Here are some more tweets of his.
https://x.com/VoteRandyFine/status/1892983275108671662
https://x.com/VoteRandyFine/status/1840207554103722459
Eughhhh.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Everything seems to be coming to a head at the same time.
I guess that makes sense when there is a common force driving all the tensions.
https://www.zerohedge.com/commodities/we-are-tipping-point-shale-giant-diamonback-says-us-oil-output-has-peaked-slashes-capex
LikeLiked by 3 people
Drill Baby Drill runs head first into physical limits. The comment section of that article is probably not worth reading.
LikeLike
A quote from the peakoilbarrel:
The yearly average will be a closer call, but it is becoming more and more obvious that we are not at the left side of the peak, but on a long, ondulating plateau. May it be long and stable enough for a transition to other energy sources! Mankind already won a decade or two with fracking and unconventional oil. Maybe one more decade and we’ll make it without bloody resource conflicts all over the world.
I’m not holding my breath.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hothouse Earth and an Ice-Free Arctic Sea. Starting in 2030?
According to one paper, there may be a single-ice free day in the Arctic as soon as 2030. There is some hopium at the end saying we still have time.
LikeLike
I haven’t done enough research to say this with any certainty, but I’d imagine an ice free arctic would cause a cascade of weather pattern shifts that would significantly disrupt global food supplies. I bet that this is what causes the first major global famine in developed countries. I’m speculating though, frankly I don’t think anyone really knows what the impacts will be because its such a complex system.
LikeLiked by 1 person
LikeLiked by 4 people
Translation; WASF
I had to look that up… freaking hilarious!
LikeLike
Israel has already turned nearly 70% percent of Gaza into “No-Go Zones”, cramming over 2 million people in an already severely overpopulated area, into less than 1/3rd of the land.
https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2025/5/6/israel-has-turned-70-of-gaza-into-no-go-zones-in-maps
LikeLike
My Canadian government is silent on the Gaza genocide.
LikeLike
Xraymike79 is taking requests. Few days ago I asked him for a Ligotti essay. He posted it last night. Hardcore doomers will love it. The Abyss Gazes Back: Pessimism as a Lens on Existential Collapse | Collapse of Industrial Civilization
The Ligotti parts were the best, but I’m way too bias… And I highly recommend putting in a request to mike.
I’m currently reading The Conspiracy Against the Human Race for the third time.😊 Ligotti has me thinking about sapiens from 200k years ago. Those first few generational waves that were born into the nightmare of full consciousness. What a crazy time it must have been.
This was a reply I got to my fire comment on Dr Tim’s blog yesterday:
I doubt anyone in this audience believes that nonsense. And it reeks of Daniel Quinn’s denial filled lunacy:
“Man was born millions of years ago, and he was no more a scourge than hawks or lions or squids. He lived at PEACE with the world … for MILLIONS of years.
This doesn’t mean he was a saint. This doesn’t mean he walked the earth like a Buddha. It means he lived as harmlessly as a hyena or a shark or a rattlesnake.
It’s not MAN who is the scourge of the world, it’s a single culture. One culture out of hundreds of thousands of cultures. OUR culture.”
I finally started reading Richard Wrangham’s ‘Catching Fire – How cooking made us human’. Should’ve been all over this back when Rob recommended it to me last year. It’s making me even more cocky about fire. I’m getting downright annoying about it😂. I had already watched a bunch of interviews with Richard, but reading is always so much more effective. Hopefully it gives me some new stuff to talk about.
Back to Ligotti. All I see in his words below is full consciousness (MORT) and the immediate need to create meaning out of nothing… all made possible from a million years of fire evolution.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I am closer to Cioran (-:
“For him, existence is a cosmic pratfall, a joke told in a language we half-understand. “We are born to exist, not to live,” he quipped, distilling the absurdity of a species that builds skyscrapers to touch the heavens while digging graves beneath its feet. In the face of climate collapse, Cioran’s laughter echoes through the smog-choked air, a sardonic soundtrack to humanity’s pantomime of progress.”
Saludos
el mar
LikeLiked by 2 people
Funny clip. Never heard of Dave Allen. Thanks.
I went to xraymike’s site to read the essay again and noticed that he has already posted three other things since this one. LOL. I would’ve kept it up for a couple weeks before posting a new one. It’s too good to be buried already.
I know he’s half man, half machine… but c’mon robomike, save some content for the rest of us to write about. LOL.
LikeLike
This may have already been posted but it’s very good.
LikeLike
Must watch. The origin of covid is becoming more widely known.
Dozens of people participated in the conspiracy.
Will anyone be held to account?
LikeLiked by 2 people
(h/t Steve Bull)
Good short video, except for this god-awful line towards the end in one of those “what would aliens say if they were observing our planet” scenarios:
Actually, it looks like a quote from Brandon Young.😂
I used to love the alien angle. Not a fan anymore (unless the aliens are clowning on humans, like They’re Made Out of Meat). I despise the fact that I fell for Dr Steven Greer’s cult. Getting duped into the noble savage myth is peanuts compared to the alien con.
Understanding that nobody in the universe has ever gotten out of their own solar system… takes a lot of the fun out of sci-fi.
LikeLike
You know what the aliens would do? They would put every camera they have on Earth and make it a reality TV show!
LikeLiked by 1 person
LOL, good one.
I never gave South Park a chance. I probably missed out on some excellent commentary.
LikeLike
Jake Park a “collapse-aware Gen Z postrationalist” recently engaged on my pinned X thread offering his excellent plausible explanations for the covid mystery of broad indifference that troubles me.
Jake just published his first essay, perhaps with help from an AI, on Substack. Those of you that appreciate a philosophical perspective on our overshoot predicament will enjoy this essay. My brain, as you know, doesn’t do philosophy.
https://jakehpark.substack.com/p/epistemic-entropy-a-postrationalist
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ah, thank you for sharing this! And I imagine you’ve picked up on the em-dashes, but I assure you that the writing is entirely mine. I promise not all of my essays will be this dense.
LikeLiked by 2 people
What software are you using for writing? There is no key on the keyboard for em dashes and no easy shortcut in Microsoft. Chat GPT puts em dashes in everything.
I got super nerdy into this because I am a professional writer and had never seen an em dash professionally until Chat GPT came along. It’s an interesting topic for me because I wonder if I should be deleting them because it gives ‘AI was here’.
This a hyphen (-).
Word automatically turns hyphens into en dashes (–) when between two words. These are typically used between date ranges, but have also replace the em dash in modern writing.
This is an em dash (—) . They are a relic of the typewriter era. I wonder if LLMs were trained on a lot of older books, hence em dashes are so common in AI???
Then there is the 3 em dash (———). Used for referencing, academia, and legal texts.
I will fight people on this (:-)), but I don’t believe anyone is actually writing em dashes on their computer. It is a clear sign that AI was present. Some people swear they write with em dashes. But I think they mean en dashes.
The novel, “When Hitler Stole Pink Rabbit” by Judith Kerr makes exceptional use of em dashes. They are throughout the book. Even back in the early 2000s I found these em dashes highly unusual!
Judith used em dashes beautifully to interrupt her narrative with vivid descriptions. Her description of the Russian steppes was particularly enthralling. She clearly wrote her work on a typewriter.
Check out this sample of her writing here: http://www.lovereading4kids.co.uk/extract/1295/When-Hitler-Stole-Pink-Rabbit-by-Judith-Kerr.html
LikeLike
I have used em-dashes all my life. I write on my phone, and you can long press the hyphen to get an em-dash on most mobile keyboards. On my PC, I’ve always copy-and-pasted or used a custom key code.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Moreover, if you think an AI could seriously write like I did in my essay, you have not used AI.
Envoyé depuis Proton Mail pour Android
LikeLike
Here’s proof: https://imgur.com/a/PlKVoN0
Mildly pissed about AI, actually, because now if I write too well, people assume I used it—even though if you actually use AI, it’s abundantly clear that AI sucks at writing.
Envoyé depuis Proton Mail pour Android
LikeLike
Please don’t be pissed, I haven’t read your essay. I am just commenting on em dashes because they have been top of my mind lately / driving me mad 🙃
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh, it was a figure of speech. I’m not pissed at you. And yeah, I figured you hadn’t read my essay, because it’s very obvious it couldn’t have been AI-generated.
LikeLike
By the way, I don’t blame you for assuming I’m lying, although I fail to see what motivation I would have to lie. Here’s a fun test: copy the first paragraph of my essay, and ask it if it’s likely to have been written by an AI or human. Here’s what I get: https://imgur.com/a/HPMfdu5
Envoyé depuis Proton Mail pour Android
LikeLike
I apologise for the spam, but I’m brainstorming a standard response I can use the next time someone falsely calls me out for this, just so I never have to think about it again. Bear with me! 😛
I’m quite surprised you haven’t seen the em-dash in recent works. Here’s two examples from the last two ebooks I opened—no cherry-picking, just random pages: https://imgur.com/a/XdJEpE0
The first is Ten Arguments for Deleting Your Social Media Accounts Right Now by Jaron Lanier, and the second is Helgoland by Carlo Rovelli, which I also referenced in my essay.
LikeLike
I’m impressed. You have encyclopedic knowledge of philosophy.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hehe, appreciated! I was always hyperlexic, and then I got stuck at home for almost two years with long COVID. Couldn’t really have gone differently. ;p
LikeLiked by 1 person
No worries at all for the spam! I didn’t know you could make em dashes on your phone. That might be another place where chat gpt has picked them up from. I really have never seen em dashes in business writing or government writing, I live in NZ. It could be to do with Microsoft Word not having an easy way to insert them. And most people for work write in Word.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ah, hello neighbour! Australia here. And yes, I wouldn’t be surprised if you haven’t seen it in business writing. But em-dashes have been all over literature and the internet forever—I feel like I must be the only one who remembers!
Envoyé depuis Proton Mail pour Android
LikeLiked by 1 person
Sorry, I have learned something! I really didn’t expect any young people to be intentionally using em dashes outside of academia. I think they are easier to do on a Mac, than on a PC. It raises an interesting thought about how technology shapes us and how we communicate has humans 🙂 I will read your essay, I am partial to a bit of philosophy. Have you read ‘The Reenchantment of the World’ by Morris Berman? It is a wonderful history of the philosophy behind science. I think you would like it, though you may hate the ending because he didn’t really know how to handle “what comes next?”
LikeLiked by 1 person
No need to apologise! It’s perfectly reasonable to assume my generation to be illiterate—because we are. I’m probably the only Gen Z in a ten-kilometre radius that’s read more than 50 books in the past year. I haven’t read Berman, but the synopsis seems roughly in line with my own view! Do let me know what you think of my essay!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I have finished now. you will definitely like Morris Berman’s work. That book of his is saying the same thing as you. It is astounding that the more we “know” and the more complex our models become, the less help our experts actually are in the real world. You will like it here on un-denial. Vibing through the collapse is a solic way forward!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I read the book, and it is quite excellent. It’s marvellous how we all seem to converge upon the same ideas, but just with different terminology. The goal of my essay, in a sense, was in large part to concisely show how many thinkers are saying the exact same thing: Adam Curtis, Buddha, Lacan, Durkheim… I was aware of the cybernetic model, but felt it would defeat the purpose of concision to include in my essay. But I am surprised I missed Berman! Thank you for this recommendation—I will be citing him in future essays. Some favourite quotes:
*Everyone, says Laing — executives, physicians, waiters, or whatever — playacts, manipulates, in order to avoid being manipulated himself. The aim is the protection of the self, but since that self is in fact cut off from any meaningful intercourse, it suffocates. The environment becomes increasingly unreal as human beings distance themselves from the events of their own lives. As this process accelerates, the self begins to fight back, to nag itself (and thus create a further split) about the existential guilt it has come to feel.”
“Newton was echoing the major theme of the scientific Revolution: our goal is how, not why. That I cannot explain gravity is irrelevant. I can measure it, observe it, make predictions based on it, and this is all the scientist has to do. If a phenomenon is not measurable, it can ‘have no place in experimental philosophy.’ This philosophical position, in its various forms called ‘positivism,’ has been the public face of modern science down to the present day.”
“In the ‘Apology,’ Socrates is aghast that artisans learn and pursue their craft by ‘sheer instinct,’ that is, by social osmosis and personal intuition. As Nietzsche pointed out, the phrase ‘sheer instinct,” which in Socrates’ mouth could only be an expression of contempt, epitomized the attitude of Greek rationalism toward any other mode of cognition. For this reason, he found Socrates (and indeed all of Western civilization) tragically inverted.”
“The person in search of integration may be permanenently scared off, or forced to undertake his or her search from the very beginning. At the very worst, the eruption of unconscious information can dismember the soul, result in psychosis. The alchemical process is often summed up in the phrase ‘solve et coagula’; the persona is dissolved (on the psychic level) so as to enable the real Self to coagulate, or come together. But as R.D. Laing points out in ‘The Politics of Experience,’ there is no guarantee that this Self will coagulate; indeed, such a result may be especially unlikely in a culture that is terrified of the unconscious and rushes to drug the individual back into what it defines as reality.”
– This one in particular is a word-for-word translation of my description of psychosis/the Dark Night.
“I know of no logical way to demonstrate that the denial of participation is the cause of radical relativism, and I am not advancing a causal argument of that sort; but they do seem to exhibit an observable pattern of interdependence.”
Learning I, II and III appear to correspond to the Kegan stages of development, or roughly the Buddhist paths.
Schismogenesis appears roughly analogous to Lacan’s jouissance.
“I have already noted Bateson’s example of the hypothetical television set that reports on its own internal workings as an illustration of the limits of consciousness. We see the paradox at once: it is as though I were to say to you, ‘Speak to me about what you are speaking as you are speaking it.’ In order for the television to report on the workings that make possible that very report, another unit would have to be added to it. But since this new unit could not report on its own workings, a unit would have to be added to that, and so on. One would soon confront an infinite regress, a set of Chinese puzzle boxes. The attempt of the conscious mind to explicate its own mode of operation involves the same sort of paradox.”
– This is an elegant layman’s description of the Turing halting problem.
I only disagree with Berman’s conclusion that a transition to Learning III is inevitable. I am not so sure that is where we’re headed.
Again, thank you for the engagement!
LikeLiked by 1 person
man you read that quick – like seriously! Im glad you liked it 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2025/may/07/israel-starving-gaza
Israel is starving Gaza. It’s a cheap, silent and brutal way to kill
LikeLiked by 2 people
I just added the new documentary “Louis Theroux: The Settlers” to my library. A skim suggests it will be excellent for understanding the Israeli mindset since it lets the Israelis explain their actions in their own words.
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt36640622/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Louis_Theroux:_The_Settlers
LikeLike
I wonder how the IDF will spin it, “Hamas made us kill 2 million children”. Beyond evil
LikeLike
Alice Friedemann highly recommends a book on nuclear energy.
My views on nuclear are much simpler than Ramana’s:
https://energyskeptic.com/2025/nuclear-is-definitely-not-the-solution/
LikeLiked by 1 person
The (former) archdruid just posted about peak oil over at ecosophia. Sounds like he is going to write on occasion on that topic again. He’s still arguing the slow descent scenario.
While I find Hideaway’s fragile complexity a compelling analysis, I also recognize that there are formidable forces that will pull out all stops to keep BAU going, even at the price of more inequity and authoritarianism.
JMG’s storyline does describe punctuated stair-step catabolic collapse, so even in this case, some change will be rapid.
Either way, we are on our own to make personal preparations.
LikeLiked by 2 people
The system has wanted to contract since 2008 and we’ve used every trick in the book to prevent it building pressure in the process so my intuition says we should expect a fast drop but I also understand the system is so complex that there is no way to predict what will happen.
LikeLiked by 2 people
We could add a many more industries to Bill’s brilliant joke…. military, healthcare, police, politics, financial investment, telemarketing… actually, it would be easier and more accurate if we just replace “in advertising or marketing” with “human”.😊
(unfortunately this clip isn’t the full bit, but it’s still worth watching)
LikeLiked by 1 person
You’ll like this article.
https://georgetsakraklides.substack.com/p/technophilia-the-mental-illness-behind?r=4mkmev&utm_medium=ios&triedRedirect=true
“The reason for all this complexity is the very nature of civilisation: highly fragmented, specialised yet globalised, but most of all, commodified down to the water we drink and the air we breathe. And with commoditisation comes branding. Branding is the science of lying. Product branding is the equivalent of a confessional sacrament: products walk in, confess all their carbon sins in secrecy, then receive the blessing to freely roam out into the world and destroy it. I worked in marketing, branding and advertising for two decades. My full-time job was to help products make false statements, that is, to claim that they are useful and benign. From online casinos to soft drinks, pet foods to the defence industry, I helped my multibillion-dollar clients highlight the “value” of their useless and dangerous products to their customers. As I was compensated to do this work for the world’s biggest multinational corporations, in the end I actually offered nothing of value to this planet: nothing other than making the productization process even more carbon intensive, expensive, and destructive to all 10 million life forms on Earth, including humans themselves.
So, the problem isn’t merely the quantities of useless single-use goods we consume, but the entire “civilisational set up” that produces them: the complex, convoluted, wasteful chain of processes that monetize and brand these goods, upon which the monster we call “the economy” depends. The entire sequence of extraction, manufacture and disposal is a funeral procession where real life forms, resources and even humans are sacrificed just so that this death cult we call the economy can continue to register record profits.”
Cheers
LikeLiked by 2 people
Good essay Campbell, thanks. Was checking out some of George’s recent work and it’s much better than I remember his older work being. A while back I had to stop reading his blog because I sensed too much denial.
Either I got that completely wrong, or George is similar to me where his awareness level (which includes denial control) has shot through the roof in the last year or so.
LikeLiked by 1 person
He posts regularly on LinkedIn with, unsurprisingly, very little engagement there with what he writes.
LikeLiked by 1 person
@Rob, Someone posted this in the Great simplification Discord server.
BREAKING: COVID-19 mRNA Shots Destroy Over 60% of Women’s Non-Renewable Egg SupplyNew study finds rats injected intramuscularly with human-equivalent mRNA doses suffered irreversible loss of primordial follicles — the foundation of fertility.
https://www.thefocalpoints.com/p/breaking-covid-19-mrna-shots-destroy
LikeLike
Thanks Stellar. If true it doesn’t surprise me.
When you inject software that does not stay local to the injection site, is long lasting, has a wildly variable effective dose rate between individuals, and is compatible with every cell in every organ, and it instructs cells to manufacture a protein that is foreign to the body thus causing the immune system to attack and kill the cell, it’s not surprising that we see every manner of disease including infertility.
LikeLike
In addition, probable clots.
Sigh, no mention of Dr. Joe Lee’s plausible prediction of clots from mRNA transfections.
https://substack.com/inbox/post/163255744
LikeLike
Worldwide oil consumption is 105 million barrels per day. Thats 38 billion per year. So one of largest oil field discoveries in the last 40 years has a grand total of 3 or 4 months of global BAU… hmm
Out of my element anytime I’m talking about oil, and it feels like something is off with my math. This all started from an article I saw about some new oil field that was estimated to have ten million barrels in the ground. Article was pumping it up with excitement. I was cracking up at how the entire quantity of that field will power civilization for a mighty two hours. LOL.
So that got me looking into it more. List of oil fields – Wikipedia
25,000 made me laugh at first glance… but ok, 1500 is more reasonable. If I upgrade those 1500 major fields to supergiants with 10 billion barrels… we’ll have 391 years of BAU (at a consumption rate of 105 mill per day). Ok, so that’s unrealistic. Lets go with the 1500 sites averaging 1 billion… that gives us 40 years. How about 100 million barrels per field… 4 years till the lights go out. Ok, now we’re talking!
Sorry but I have no point here… just rambling because my brain got hung up on the 105 million barrels per day thing. Where the hell is it coming from? And how the hell is it not dried up by now? Ugh, when is this grave robbing gonna end.
The Clash is too mainstream for me to be recommending, but I can’t help it. Been jamming to this song all night.
LikeLiked by 2 people
It is mind boggling how much biomass had to grow, accumulate, and cook for us to burn 100 million barrels a day.
I like to convert to liters so my brain can better imagine it.
100,000,000 barrels = 15,900,000,000 liters PER DAY !!
LikeLiked by 3 people
that’s such a large number that I have trouble wrapping my head around it, so I tried dividing it by world population; then it’s 2 liters per person per day, for everyone on the planet. Looking at it from a calories point of view (yes I know you can’t eat crude oil, but I think it’s an interesting perspective), I read that 159 liters (a barrel) of crude and equals 5.8 million BTU, for 36478 BTU/l, and that 1 BTU = 252 calories…so 18,384,905 calories per day, if I’ve not made a mistake somewhere! That’s enough to feed about 7500 people per day. Jancovici (sp?) talks about energy slaves, but I think he mentions something like 200 energy slaves per day…which makes me wonder if my math is wrong, or if reality is even more bonkers than he suggests.
LikeLiked by 2 people
2 liters per person per day is a great way to think of it. Now imagine having a plot of land and growing enough biomass to make 2 liters of diesel a day. I think it’s a miracle that the earth somehow accumulated so much fossil energy.
I think Jancovici is high, although he may be talking about rich countries which use a lot more than the average.
Here’s my rough calculation:
20TW = 20 * 10 ** 12 watts = total energy used by humans
8 billion = 8 * 10 ** 9 = human population
100 watts = respiration energy per adult human
20 * 10 ** 12 / 8 * 10 ** 9 / 100 = 25 slaves per person
LikeLiked by 1 person
LOL, you guys made me get in on the act…
Converted to liquor, 1.5 ounce shot glass = 376 billion shots a day (46 per person).
This clip might be closer to reality than I thought. 😊
LikeLiked by 1 person
Here is one take on the energy slave question. I am liking this Eric Lee guy. Quirky, but does research.
https://alysion42.substack.com/p/energy-slaves-29c276da6d7f
His very last sentence in the article was a good zinger.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Good essay, thanks!
LikeLike
there is a mistake in the units here, as i used calories rather than kilocalories (the typical measurement for food). 36,748 BTU is 9,195 kilocaories, so on the basis of 2,500 kilocalories to feed one person, 2l crude oil/day equates to enough oil energy to feed 7 people.
I think your take of looking at it from a biofuel PoV is interesting; according to https://hungermath.wordpress.com/2015/10/29/how-much-farmland-is-used-for-biofuel/, canola oil yields 226 kg/acre…assuming that canola oil has approx the same density as water, that means we’d need just over 3 acres per person of biofuel to get to that 2l/day figure for crude oil, or 25,840,707,964 acres total for 8 billion people. There’s a total of 4.62 billion acres of land globally used for agriculture, so we’d need to be farming about 5.6 planet earths to achieve that. Then another planet for the actual food, of course!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Arguably, gasoline prices in the US are far too low. They do not to come close to reflecting how valuable oil truly is, and what it took for it to form.
LikeLike
Your point leads to an interesting thought experiment.
On the one hand, diesel is incredibly valuable and we should happily pay 100 times more for it because the alternative of hiring slaves to do the same work is more expensive.
On the other hand, modernity requires growing complexity and plentiful credit, both of which require growing energy use, which requires diesel to be be priced lower than it is today.
So maybe modernity is not compatible with fair value based commodity prices.
LikeLike
I’m back from our holiday to New Guinea. I spent a lot of time re-reading a lot from anthropologists like Bendall, Catton, Tainter, Levitt and others, plus I’ve been looking up their references since getting back.
They all seem to acknowledge ‘resource depletion’ or ‘resource constraints’ but none seem to understand the physics of EROEI, nor do any consider that civilization is a physical process.
Also when considering modernity compared to past civilizations they miss an important aspect. Past civilizations all used grass, grain and wood as their primary energy sources for most of their energy. Grass and grain fed to animals, grain and animals fed to humans, and wood for heating, charcoal etc. These are all naturally growing commodities with relatively easy production methods, so that the peasantry could continue with these activities even as the ‘civilization’ was crumbling around them. None of them required products from the heart of the civilization to go out to the rural areas, except for ‘protection’ from barbarians..
Even mining was a relatively simple activity, with simple iron tools.
In modernity, the primary energy for food, heat and mining are fossil fuel derived, they don’t grow locally. The peasantry (us farmers) can’t produce and ship to the city without the aid of fossil fuels. Comparing ancient civilization’s and their collapses to modern times is like comparing chalk to cheese.
LikeLiked by 4 people
Welcome back, we missed you.
It seems you are on to an important new idea. Your book could replace Catton’s as the new overshoot bible.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I think the problem is that there is always another piece to the puzzle of the big picture which is what I keep finding.
Anthropologists just don’t get the EROEI equation that collecting wood and grain from 50km out of the city is less efficient than collecting from 5-10km, so in the longer term the overall efficiency of the activity is falling. As the civilization grew, the resources came from further afield and from declining soils and forests, so double trouble on the EROEI front. A civilization stretching from 0 to 20-30 km from the ‘city’ probably gained in efficiency with better roads, better bred animals, better tools, but reached a size where distance/quality of resources ate into EROEI.
All while this is happening, the best and closest grades of whatever is mined, whether sand, rock, clay or metals is always mined first. They also have laws of diminishing return applied, meaning a multiplication of the falling EROEI, with less efficient gathering of grains, wood and grass, feeding lower efficiencies of mining requiring more ‘energy’ to this endeavor. Even though totals of mined commodities can show increases, the net increase to society is reduced after all the added energy costs.
It seems that inequality starts to kick in when the technology/complexity gains cease and start to reverse, so inequality is a feature of civilizations past their prime and just another part of the overall physical process of civilization.
Our civilization was at it’s greatest point of equality in the ’60’s, right when energy growth, especially the most useful energy, oil, was greatest. It was a time of exponential growth in oil production. I’m certain it’s not a coincidence, it’s part of the overall process. As oil production ceased to grow exponentially and went to linear growth, while the EROEI started to decline, was when modernity started to become more unequal. We now have the greatest inequality in the ‘rich’ countries in many decades, and are heading towards more inequality.
Anthropologists always seem to be looking at the human element/excuse for the collapse of civilizations and not the underlying physics of what’s happening.
LikeLiked by 4 people
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Johann_Heinrich_von_Th%C3%BCnen#:~:text=Johann%20Heinrich%20von%20Th%C3%BCnen%20(24,Strelitz%2C%20now%20in%20northern%20Germany.&text=Even%20though%20he%20never%20held,had%20substantial%20influence%20on%20economics.
Thünen’s model of agricultural land, created before industrialization, made the following simplifying assumptions:
The use which a piece of land is put to is a function of the cost of transport to market and the land rent a farmer can afford to pay (determined by yield, which is held constant here).
The model generated four concentric rings of agricultural activity. Dairying and intensive farming lies closest to the city. Since vegetables, fruit, milk and other dairy products must get to market quickly, they would be produced close to the city.
Saludos
el mar
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks el mar, I’m sure you can see the problems with the assumptions. Here is another further down the article… “The use which a piece of land is put to is a function of the cost of transport to market and the land rent a farmer can afford to pay (determined by yield, which is held constant here)“
….”The city is located centrally within an “Isolated State.”
Where is ‘isolated on planet Earth at the time of initial agriculture?
…..”The Isolated State is surrounded by wilderness.“
That wilderness had threats to human agricultural development, from both other humans and wild animals..
…. “The land is completely flat and has no rivers or mountains.“
So not on planet Earth, and not suitable for irrigation.
…..”Soil quality and climate are consistent.“
….”Farmers in the Isolated State transport their own goods to market via oxcart, across land, directly to the central city. There are no roads.“
… Of course, by tracking across other farmers higher yielding vegetable and fruit crops, those farmers never get upset, they just expect to lose a proportion of every crop to other farmers crossing their land, with their oxen carts. Of course its’ ridiculous in the real world as roads/tracks are an essential part of any civilization..
……”Farmers behave rationally to maximize profits.“
This is straight out of modern economics where all players behave rationally. Sure a farmer that’s been growing fruit (trees) for decades is going to rip them all out because vegetables are more profitable this year. (NOT!!)
People are irrational creatures, not rational which is why economics can never predict when a boom will bust or when the next recession will come along. What’s the famous saying about economists… “Some have picked 15 of the last 4 recessions”.
Why would anyone make an assumption about rationality for a species, when the species mostly believes in some deity will save them and allow them to live after they die, which is clearly irrational???
BTW I loved this spacial geography stuff when at high school and did a lot of this at university, but even back then, 50 years ago (ahhh!!), I started questioning professors about stupid assumptions…
Any of us could make a list of unrealistic assumptions to show a bright green future of humans exploring the galaxy in the next few hundred years, providing we took a blind eye to the reality of the world around us..
LikeLiked by 4 people
Just a further follow up to my previous comment to discuss this: “Anthropologists always seem to be looking at the human element/excuse for the collapse of civilizations and not the underlying physics of what’s happening.”
Yes that is entirely correct. The whole focus is on people – it is how the discipline works. It is something that drove me mad when I was studying anthropology. They often ignore natural things like resources, geography, and biology as explanations for human behaviour and choices. Luckily I was also studying history and classics – so I got a better rounded education.
That is probably why I role my eyes when economists, scientists, and engineers think they’ll find answers to our predicament in the social sciences. A la Nate Hagens and co. Most of what you get from anthropologists and sociologists is post-modern frameworks, narratives, and word salad. Make it intersectional for bonus points of nonsense LOL.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Thankyou Monk!! This explains my frustration the more I read from so many different experts in different fields, the latest being, going over what anthropologists have come up with..
Physicists/physical scientists studying the predicament mostly believe in the power of science to solve the problem and economists who use money to fix everything…
Economists believe in money and ingenuity of humans to solve everything..
Anthropologists believe in understanding the human influence will help solve things, so their work is relevant in helping us to avoid the poor decision making of the past..
Geologists expect human ingenuity to find new ways to gain access to more resources, solving everything with more money, al la economists..
Climatologists expect human ingenuity to solve climate problems, with a ‘simple’ (ROFLMAO) transition the solution to all our problems..
None of them really have a clue, as they don’t understand what’s actually happening in the real world as they are lost in their own cubicle of the problem, while surrounded by others just as trapped in like minded thinking within their own little cubicles of expertise.
To understand our predicament, that is basic physics as the underlying principle, requires a general understanding of physics, biology/ecosystems, economics, anthropology, geology and system dynamics, and enough understanding of maths and statistics to put the whole picture together..
LikeLiked by 2 people
Just saw this comment on Crazy Eddy’s blog and it instantly made me think of yours and monk’s comment.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Wow I love that comment – I didn’t know Jack of All Trades was missing the ending.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Those civilizations were all closer to the almighty important 100% on the farm ratio… everybody knowing how to do the essentials.
With the added bonus that the ratio has now flipped to under 10% on the farm… nobody knowing how to do the essentials.
The most pampered and useless humans in all of history (Homo Inutilis) are gonna go down fast & furious… from a distance it might even look like Mother Nature is in that psychotic mode of “terminate with extreme prejudice”.
Good post Hideaway. I hope JMG reads it.😊
LikeLike
Great points Chris, yes having the mass of the population still in the rural areas gathering food/fuel was a commonality of all pre fossil fuel civilizations, giving another reason why today’s modern civilization of over 50% of the world’s population urbanised and over 80% in most developed nations, is just not comparable.
How is it anthropologists miss these important details? Easy, they think the systems/links are all human based and not part of physical laws.
Also in the old civilizations, cities relied upon the rural population for everything, while the rural population required very little form the city, and could certainly cope without inputs from the city. In today modern civilization, the rural areas totally rely upon the distribution of fuel, fertilizers, pesticides, products etc from factories in cities to survive, often factories overseas..
Alice Friedmann has the great book …When the Trucks Stop Running… I think she should include …When the Ships Stop Running into the title…..
LikeLiked by 3 people
Ships, trucks, tractors, and combines.
I’ve threshed grain by hand. I think combines are our most useful application of diesel.
Gail Zawacki had garbage trucks at the top of her list given what life would be like without them.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Anthropologists do not typically study macro-level. It is not part of the discipline. Anthropology is primarily concerned with the detailed, context-specific study of particular communities, cultures, and
practices, normally done through ethnographic fieldwork. Anthropologists may interpret their findings using broader theoretical frameworks, including those borrowed from other disciplines – but they don’t do the broad sweeping stuff. That is what historians and sociologists do.
I have an undergraduate degree in all three 🙂
LikeLike
That’s dedication. Hideaway hasn’t had time to unpack and wash his underwear and he’s already hammering the peak oil barrel crowd that denies the implications of peak oil.
https://peakoilbarrel.com/january-non-opec-and-world-oil-production-drops/#comment-788913
LikeLiked by 4 people
LikeLike
Not that I support it but how do we know that this is real.
Something just to spread the hate evenly both ways.
Here’s an idea, everyone die, then there are no squabbles.
Perhaps we should put up all the muslim rape stuff too, just to ramp up the rhetoric.
On the face of things we don’t appear to be a species worth saving.
Gaza maybe hell but don’t worry it is coming for all of us one collapse at a time.
LikeLike
I watched this last night and thought of you, Rob; it’s an exploration of Machiavelli’s “The Prince”, looking at why incompetent idiots end up as rulers. Summary from the description:
The Machiavellian Paradox: Why intelligence can be a liability in power games
The Confidence Illusion: How boldness and charisma outperform actual skill
The Incompetence Network: How weak leaders surround themselves with yes-men
The Simplicity Trap: Why the public prefers clear, wrong answers to complex truths
The Ethical Handicap: How moral integrity blocks advancement in toxic systems
Toxic Environments: Where mediocrity thrives—and how to reverse the dynamic
Mass Distraction Tactics: How manipulative leaders maintain control and appear competent
Breaking the Cycle: Strategies to resist manipulation and promote merit-based leadership
LikeLiked by 1 person
I really like this one from Crazy Eddy tonight. The Greatest Disasters in Human History
Probably AI generated but that’s fine, it got me thinking and that’s all I care about. I thought I had stumbled onto a new angle with fire leading to full consciousness/MORT. Every item on Eddy’s list is within the last few thousand years except for fire which he says is 2 million years old. So why does nothing happen for that long of time until a few thousand years ago? Obviously because something crazy happened to humans only recently… Oh ya, I was really onto something here😊… but then of course reality slapped me in the face by reminding me of something called the Holocene.
I really hate the Hollywood Holocene story… humans were getting too good at hunting and killing off all the megafauna. Soon they would be out of food and go extinct. But at the 11th hour the clouds parted ways, and sunny days were here to stay. Gardens sprang out of the ground everywhere.
LOL, but you get the point… there is way too much human drama involved in that story… which automatically means bullshit. My fire story would be so much easier to sell if I didn’t have to include the goddamn Holocene part.😂
ps. I’m not 100% sure what Eddy is saying here, but it sounds like he might be unknowingly putting a date on full consciousness/MORT.
Might have to ask him where he got the 125k from. Hopefully it’s a good source. I’d have no problem believing that date. Pretty sure I haven’t seen any burial evidence that far back.
LikeLiked by 1 person
https://peakoilbarrel.com/january-non-opec-and-world-oil-production-drops/#comment-788971
LikeLiked by 2 people
https://peakoilbarrel.com/january-non-opec-and-world-oil-production-drops/#comment-788945
LikeLiked by 2 people
Another google AI Gaffe
LikeLiked by 2 people
omg that is hilarious
LikeLike
I asked Gemini AI the same thing…..
“Wow, spotting a dinosaur outside would be quite an extraordinary event! Since dinosaurs are believed to be extinct, it’s highly likely that what you’re seeing is either a misidentification, a very elaborate costume or animatronic, or perhaps even a movie prop.
However, for the sake of being prepared for any possibility, here are a few things you might consider doing:
Could you describe what you’re seeing? Maybe we can try to figure out what it might be!”
Believed to be extinct??? LOL. It shows that AI doesn’t have any intelligence at all…
LikeLiked by 2 people
I had an evil white skin sermon over at megacancer.😊 I know most of you have no interest. Only posting it here in case there’s one or two maniacs out there similar to me that find this stuff fascinating.
I don’t truly believe this stuff the way I used to back in my noble savage myth days. And I haven’t preached about it in a while. But I have to admit, it was kind of fun to put these thoughts together again.
The Naked Apemunculus – MEGACANCER
The Naked Apemunculus – MEGACANCER
LikeLike
Ya, not sure why I shared this yesterday. Or why I even wrote it in the first place. Guess I still get off on the irritation & shock value that it might bring.
Would be one thing if I still bought into it, but I just don’t anymore. It’s too similar to my flawed logic with blaming humans for causing the sixth mass extinction… back when I rejected the MPP.
My current road map for this blame game stuff looks something like this
LikeLiked by 1 person
Why blame and not love?
Aren’t the flaws and vulnerabilities the most loving aspect?
Otherwise, wouldn’t organisms be just machines?
There is much beyond the surface, behind the masks.
Matthew 5:43-47
To be more precise: study those who and that which trigger you/you dislike, understand why you do. It’s in you, first (otherwise it wouldn’t make you react). Like a seed buried down the soil, that has been brought back to the surface after a heavy rain or a landslide, now ready to bloom. Then see why they behave like that, and then you will see, they are just like you. In their vulnerabilities, in their wounds.
Best.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Just had a taste of collapse. My internet was down for most of 4 days.
The service we take for granted is a VERY complex system with many possible failure points.
Was it caused by some dodgy amplifier on their nearby lines that doesn’t work properly except in the cool hours of the late evening and early morning, or maybe because I’m at the end of a long trunk and the signal is marginal requiring a perfect modem, or maybe the radar emissions from the nearby coast guard office fried some of their lines and they did not make a perfect repair, or maybe it’s the 30 years of splitters and crap coax in my crawlspace that degraded the signal and forced to me work in an confined area I hate and clean it up, or maybe a chip in the super complex modem went of our spec, perhaps aggravated by my “custom” mods to shut off their goddamn wi-fi radios because I have a much better high end router, or maybe it was a combination of all of the above.
Three hours in a chat line queue waiting for a customer service rep in India to tell me to cycle the power which I had already done dozens of times, and then to notify him when it rebooted except this killed my chat connection, followed by another 2 hours in a chat queue to speak to a different person and repeating my story, followed by a technician plus truck visiting my home, followed by a more senior technician in a bigger truck, followed by the system failing again shortly after he left, followed by both technicians having to return later in the day with both trucks, plus a hundred feet of cable we don’t make in Canada, plus trying 4 different modems from two different manufacturers, neither in Canada, until we found one modem that was “just right”, and I’m back up, for a while anyway.
I can imagine a lot of complexity vaporizing in a hell of hurry when SHTF.
Not having internet causes a weird panicky feeling. And I still had some (slow) internet available via my cell phone.
It will take some time to adjust to the old ways.
LikeLiked by 3 people
I know the feeling of panic. Maybe collapse has started, maybe a war has broken out, is it a repeat “Carrington” event? At the time my internet went down for a few days last winter it ultimately was that a contractor in the town 20 miles away (close to my ISP) cut a large trunk line and the ISP did not have a second route into their servers. At that time I did not have cell phone service at my home because Verizon refuses to put in a cell tower in our rural area. I have since switched cell providers so I can get internet either through coax or cell. I now really fear when both go out simultaneously.
AJ
LikeLiked by 2 people
Rob, every system we all take for granted is the same, highly complex. Imagine the number of factories operating all over the place making parts that are constantly necessary to keep the whole operating. When that supply chain starts to fail, problems develop all over the place at the same time, the system will break down quickly.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Based on what you described, I am guess you get your internet from a cable company. Cable was originally designed to carry TV signals, and internet piggybacked on top of that.
I suspect that the next round of crises we face will be the death blow for Cable TV (which is already in a death spiral). It will also be the end many websites and streaming services as well.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I do have cable internet but I believe they use optical fiber to deliver it to my neighborhood. I cancelled my cable TV and phone last year. Don’t miss it. I have enough video stored offline to keep me amused until I die.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Maybe that’s what you will be sharing post-collapse of the macro-system. When, the wind will be blowing (the only time there will be some electricity, thanks to small-scale repairable turbine, made out of wood https://solar.lowtechmagazine.com/2019/06/reinventing-the-small-wind-turbine/), it will be movie time for the community at Rob’s 🙂
(unless another route is taken: https://solar.lowtechmagazine.com/2020/05/thermoelectric-stoves-ditch-the-solar-panels/)
Best!
LikeLiked by 2 people
Nate Hagen’s says the coming great simplification will force us to like and hang out with our neighbors.
I may be watching movies alone.
LikeLiked by 1 person
So you have chosen the path of the hermit? If so, there shouldn’t be any regrets.
Mark 12:30-31
The desert is not the final destination, only a passage in the journey.
If you accept, here is an assignment for you. Next time you have the urge to talk about covid or collapse to a person in real life (who you know doesn’t want to hear it, for now). Just pause, take a breath. Listen to the inner voice and smile to him. Tell him you understand the need and his fear. Soothe/reassure him. But, be firm and tell him, to wait, that it is not his turn to speak this time. Then smile to the person you are with and just listen to what they are saying. Look in their eyes, see the wrinkles, the grain of the skin, watch the expressions and the emotions. See the underlying light. Let things go their way. Smile.
LikeLike
That’s very good advice but I have difficulty controlling my anger about covid.
Ignorance/denial about overshoot is totally understandable because there are no solution. There is no excuse for covid ignorance/denial.
Covid would not have happened without our governments funding dangerous unethical gain of function research. After the man-made virus got loose there were many good responses that would have prevented most deaths, none of which we chose. The responses we chose harmed more people than the virus, and made the pandemic worse. When the pandemic (panic) ended, there were many things we could have done to prevent a recurrence, but we did none.
My fellow idiot citizens understand none of this.
LikeLike
Thank you for your answer.
Yes, I understand. Then, I think you have to do something about it. For yourself and for the world. Listen to your anger. If it can’t be appeased, just by recognizing its presence, then do something with it. If you let it burn inside, it will turn into a demon.
You can work with it instead. Turn it into positive energy. It will fade, once the task you have to perform is done.
I don’t know, what precisely, you need to do about this. Only you know. By listening deeply to yourself. It may be that you contact an organization that is trying to file lawsuits. Or it may be that you volunteer for an association which helps people who have been harmed by the vaccine. Or it may be that you need to make different opponents of covid vaccines discuss with one another so that a comprehensive picture emerges. Or it may be that you create your own local investigation group. Maybe, you can start by handing out flyers from house to house in your neighborhood. Maybe, you can ask paqnation a helping hand: after all he is an expert salesman, he worked in the field and knows the art of communicating with people. Maybe, you visit the doctors in your region, or the corroners and ask if they can help with that. Maybe you contact lawyers and ask them what can be done (at the local, regional, state level…)
In any case, if I may, do not be agressive to people, don’t try to convince those who will not listen. You will find many others who have doubts, are more open, and also strong allies. Take your time.
I don’t know what you need to do. You know better than me. If you don’t find, just by listening to yourself, then make a list of all the potential things you could do. Sort them by easiest to hardest. And sort them by the ones you want to do most and the one you want to do least. Then pick a thing and try it out. Taste it. If it works out well, it will lead you to the next step. If it doesn’t then you can always go back to the list, without regrets, having learned something about the true nature of your desire.
All you need to know is the grand thing you want to achieve and the next small step in its direction.
I think you particularly excel at organizing things (mental and physical). So maybe, you can help a team of lawyers make sense of all the data they receive in relation to covid, in order to build a strong case, find the truth, expose it and judge those that pulled the levers. And avoid it reproduces (at least for a while ;).
I know you can. You have to: anger may burn, but it doesn’t lie. I wish you the best. You are a great and strong person.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you Charles. You have a lot of wisdom. I’ve bookmarked your reply and will think about actions I can take to find a channel for the anger.
I’m pessimistic because very few people care about this issue. Those that allowed themselves to be deceived don’t want to acknowledge the implications of being deceived. Those that orchestrated and amplified the deceit don’t want to lose their reputations and jobs.
I expect we might discuss and acknowledge covid reality when this generation of leaders is dead, however by then we’ll be so far into overshoot collapse that food and energy scarcity will be the only topics people will want to discuss.
LikeLike
Thank you for your kind words.
Yes, you are right. And it seems to be true in general: to me, there is never any guarantee for any action to bear the expected fruits.
I feel like this: “Do what feels deeply right to you, regardless of the outcome. This is love. Like when you are riding your motorcycle.”
It can be a very small step. I will be rooting for you.
🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Great comment Charles.
My white skin rant the other day, and this post by you are very similar… in that we both knew there was a good chance that most of the audience would be rolling their eyes at it. The big difference though is intent. While I’m trying to be a pest… you’re genuinely trying to help. Love that about you. It’s why you’ll always be employed as my spiritual advisor.
ps. We can definitely help Rob turn it into positive energy… and a shitload of money. The road show act was gonna just be me and Hideaway but instead we’ll make it a three-man team. For the first 50 minutes of our act, they’ll both be the villains scaring the hell out of crowd with their scale/complexity, MORT and mRNA content.
Then I come out for the last ten minutes and save the day. I’ll astonish the audience with stories of rituals and dazzle them with official sounding terms like geoengineering, nuclear fusion, and the seventh generation principle.
I’ll put them at ease with the mRNA stuff by explaining how their government is required to lie sometimes (always for the protection of their own citizens), but they would never lie about something this important. And how having a population of healthy, informed citizens has always been the govt’s top priority.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ah ah ah. Nice gig 🙂
LikeLike
Source: https://www.dasgelbeforum.net/index.php?id=672887
On April 30, 2025 , attorney Dr. Michael-Paul Parusel, with offices in Heidelberg and Vienna ( https://www.ra-parusel.at/ ), filed a criminal complaint against 52 leading figures from science and politics in Germany for colluding in deceiving the public with the coronavirus measures. Download the complaint here:
https://uploadnow.io/f/g3XtXBk
The lawyer Dr. Michael-Paul Parusel bases his 130-page presentation of the facts on the suspicion of the realization
• serious coercion according to § 240 StGB
• dangerous bodily harm according to §§ 223, 224 StGB crimes against humanity according to § 7 (1) No. 8 VStGB
• deprivation of liberty according to § 239 StGB
• incitement to hatred according to § 130 StGB
• crimes against humanity according to § 7 (1) No. 9 VStGB
• serious bodily harm according to §§ 223, 226 StGB
• bodily harm resulting in death according to §§ 223, 227 StGB murder according to § 211 StGB
• perverting the course of justice according to § 339 StGB
• persecuting innocent people according to § 344 StGB
• forming a criminal organization according to § 129 StGB genocide according to § 6 (1) No. 3 VStGB
as intentional, unlawful (not necessarily culpable) possible main offences, if applicable, applying to the person reported
• as an attempted offender according to §§ 22, 23 StGB
• and/or by omission according to § 13 StGB
but in any case – taking into account §§ 160 ff StPO for the public prosecutor’s office and applying to the person reported in each case –
• as a direct perpetrator according to § 25 (1) StGB
• as an indirect perpetrator according to § 25 (2) StGB
• as an instigator according to § 26 StGB
• as an accessory according to § 27 StGB.
It will be interesting to see when the ” thinking ” part of the courageous lawyer’s own soul signals during morning house calls that the renaturation of Germany cannot be stopped.
Enjoy reading the 130 pages as a substitute “Word for Sunday” and
cheerful greetings
Avicenna
—
LikeLike
Today my internet went down for 3 hours, this time without my modem unlocking from the network, which means the problem is somewhere in the network, not in my home. Or maybe there are 2 problems.
LikeLike
Interesting history on PFAS, the forever chemicals.
Hint: drinking water is worse than microwave popcorn and fast food and non-stick pans.
LikeLike
Hi Rob,
Do you know if any trustworthy person studied the link between rna-vaccines and eugenics?
Thank you.
LikeLike
Assuming this definition from Grok:
I know of no one that argues mRNA transfections have a eugenics agenda.
A few low credibility people have argued mRNA transfections have a population reduction agenda.
Many high integrity people have argued some countries used covid as an excuse to cull expensive sick elderly people with midazolam, remdesivir, ventilators, excess oxygen, withholding ivermectin which is a broad spectrum anti-viral effective against RNA viruses, and withholding antibiotics from being used to treat pneumonia which was a common fatal side effect of covid.
LikeLike
Thank you.
LikeLike
Despite Trump being a moron narcissist man-child he does have a few good people on his team.
LikeLike
https://consciousnessofsheep.co.uk/2025/05/15/peak-oil-returns/
Tim Watkins:
Without an increase in surplus energy, which unconventional oil cannot deliver – to paraphrase Art Berman, discovering that your glasshouse-grown tomatoes are too expensive to bother growing – growth becomes impossible. But the way in which it plays out is distorted by the “exorbitant privileges” within the financial system – Bolivians go hungry while Europeans consume cheap plastic goods from Asia – make it impossible to predict where shortages will materialise next. Nevertheless, the direction is clear enough. And while declining surplus energy is the real crisis, it will manifest as an updated and exponentially greater version of what happened in 2008.””
Saludos
el mar
LikeLiked by 6 people
Unfortunately, most politicians are fanatical human supremacists.
https://dothemath.ucsd.edu/2025/05/off-the-marx-hitler-spectrum/
LikeLiked by 1 person
HHH on debt and profit.
https://peakoilbarrel.com/open-thread-non-petroleum-may-10-2025/#comment-789029
LikeLiked by 2 people
Hideaway continues his MORT validation experiment…
https://peakoilbarrel.com/open-thread-non-petroleum-may-10-2025/#comment-789022
LikeLiked by 2 people
Yes. And I think this could be past tense:
LikeLike
We can’t predict how overshoot will collapse, but as it gets closer we can predict that most overshoot aware people will go woo.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I can’t tell if you were being critical of Nate? If by woo, you mean religion/god /spirituality; then I agree with you. When collapse starts and accelerates people will fall back on some form of woo, because they’ll have nothing else to support them. We here at un-denial being supreme rationalists understand that there is no meaning in the universe and our lives have no ultimate purpose other than as conduits for entropy.
AJ
LikeLiked by 3 people
I would disagree about you saying “We here at un-denial being supreme rationalists understand that there is no meaning in the universe and our lives have no ultimate purpose other than as conduits for entropy”.
Yes to being rational but I think there is purpose and meaning in our lives that we can choose to give it even if the universe displays that we don’t. This is not denial of our ultimate situation but an awareness of how precious it is to be given awareness of the big entropy machine and some of the beautiful machinations within it. I get the feeling most here feel this way too but struggle with most of our fellow travelers lack of awareness.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m with nikoB on this.
I’ve said it many times but it’s amazing to be alive as a eukaryotic multi-cellular animal with high intelligence and an extended theory of mind at the peak of what is probably possible in the universe, and to be born with defective denial genes that permit us to understand how rare and special our situation is in the universe.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Dr. Tim Morgan with another restatement of the ideas he has been discussing for years. I liked his conclusion but you can skip the rest.
Notice that he implies collapse will favor those with normal denial genes so we can expect MORT to persist in whatever remains of our species.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Hideaway on the same article…
LikeLiked by 3 people
Maybe, our leaders fear that if they spoke honestly about the situation, it would cause runs on the financial markets.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I think so. At least for the leaders that get it 🙂
LikeLike
I listened to this masterpiece last night for probably the tenth time. I know it’s been shared here many times. I’m just posting again for any new people. There are hundreds of good collapse writers out there… but there are only a handful of people (that have ever existed) with the ability to sound this smooth when talking collapse for an hour in audio/video format.
My favorite moment comes at around the 14-minute mark when Gail’s explaining her frustration from her dad’s denial of the ‘Limits to Growth’ report. She turns into a valley girl for a second and it’s hilarious. I just wish she would’ve thrown in a “gag me with a spoon”. LOL
LikeLiked by 2 people
I love that interview and have listened to it many times. I made an audio only version and keep it on my phone. Probably Sam Mitchell’s best ever interview.
No problem reposting gems here. There may be new lurkers that have not seen it.
As I age I gravitate to repeated viewings of content I love. Tonight I’m thinking The Guns of Navarone (1961).
LikeLiked by 4 people
Hey Rob and all,
some content to watch made in OZ that you may not have seen but might like. I think they are all great films that very much have a Aussie quirk about them.
Getting Square
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GEeVMJpHrLI
Two Hands
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D2JmLpnASv0
Cosi
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4TvtNFAYBmQ
Death in Brunswick
https://youtu.be/FwQfpaXNR8Y
enjoy if you can find them
LikeLike
Thanks for the tips! I was able to find them all.
LikeLike
Thanks. I’ve seen Two Hands (liked it). Will put the others on my to-do list.
My favorite Aussie films besides Mad Max and Crocodile Dundee:
Dead Calm 1989
The Castle 1997
Animal Kingdom 2010
Red Dog 2011
Walkabout (1971) has been on my radar for years but still haven’t tried it.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes those are all great films Paq. Walkabout is a good but strange film. It gives a sense of the vastness of the Australian landscape.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Galipoli is another if you haven’t seen it.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Just finished listening to it again.
It’s amazing how much ground Gail covered in one hour off the top of her head. She had a remarkable intellect.
I didn’t like Sam poking around in her personal life, it was none of his business, but I admire that Gail remained gracious.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ya that annoys me too. But I’m glad Sam went there otherwise Gail might not have shared that great story about writing a strongly worded letter to the president of Princeton for letting the kids down. Would love to get my hands on that letter. You can tell that she was good at busting balls.
Plus I like to see interviews where the person gets pushed out of their comfort zone. You get lots of information from how they react… and like you said, Gail handled it like a pro. Nothing was gonna rattle her.
LikeLiked by 3 people
OK, I Will take my punishment. I had not listened to this before even after your and Rob’s multiple recommendations. I guess as an excuse I would say that you I know all this stuff and we discuss it all the time so there’s nothing new here, but that’s kind of a cop-out. In the space of 1 hour, Gail really does hit all the nails on the head. Where she’s at is probably just about where I’m at . . . cynical, no illusions about everyone arround me’s denial, rational, atheistic, not an ounce of hopium left. The future for genus homo and lots of our fellow travelers is bleak. Earth and life will bounce back until the sun becomes a red giant and the universe continues on for trillions of years in ever-expanding entropy. NO meaning but what we give it.
So thanks again for posting it.
AJ
LikeLiked by 4 people
Why we can’t preempt collapse.
On Preempting Collapse
https://thehonestsorcerer.substack.com/p/on-preempting-collapse
Given this, Is it even possible for the economy to “de-grow” in a non-chaotic fashion? I am not 100% convinced that it’s impossible, but I suspect that is the case.
LikeLiked by 2 people
I see a lot of degrowth stuff on LinkedIn. It’s all well meaning but I don’t think they understand the levels of complexity (neither do I) and it all seems to predominantly paint a picture of comfortable lifestyles within planetary boundaries by just giving up a few luxuries in the global north to allow those in the global south to improve their living standards. Population is pretty much a banned topic.
Hideaways complexity lens along with MORT and the other key topics discussed here have me convinced the downslope will be chaotic.
LikeLiked by 5 people
Here is a video showing a modern mining operation, including the processing that happens to just make a concentrate that is shipped elsewhere for turning into copper.
Even though the process is as close to continuous as possible, for efficiency purposes, there are many minor details left out of the commentary in terms of variations in ore and how they have to manage these differences. The chemicals used are also given a hand wave treatment…
Without our modern complexity of all this machinery and computer guided operation, in most of the machines involved, we would not be able to mine this resource, even with a million human laborers..
https://youtu.be/VAiCiFD-Rjg
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks, really interesting! Lots of debt, lots of diesel, lots of electricity, lots of high-tech complexity, and they still have to ship their concentrate across the planet to Japan for another complicated process before there is any useful metal.
LikeLiked by 1 person
When looking at this type of operation, any single large piece of machinery is composed of often thousands of parts that came from hundreds if not thousands of different factories across the world.
When complexity starts to collapse these types of operations will close very quickly due to lack of spares of literally everything. Govts everywhere will try and keep fuel and ‘essentials’ going, yet have no handle on the myriad of parts, chemicals, lubricants also continually required, no be able to source them.
None of our industrial civilization can run without complete supply chains, so when complexity starts to unravel, then the supply of materials to every factory in the world also quickly unravels, bringing production of just about everything to a standstill, which means no parts making it out to all the businesses that require specialist widgets..
Reading the latest “Honest Sorcerer” who is in the long slow collapse camp, just frustrates me for the lack of overall understanding of how the world actually works..
LikeLiked by 5 people
Hideaway, you just made me wonder if having a “real” job in the real economy is a pre-requisite for understanding fast collapse…
My perspective changed a lot between university and working in infrastructure. When you are in theory land it is harder to see how fragile the whole system is. I have been amazed the last 10 years that things have stood up as well as they have!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Good points. Don’t forget the tires on those giant trucks and excavators. I’ve watched videos of them being made.
I don’t read much of the Honest Sorcerer any more. Seems to have lost his clarity of thought.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The Honest Sorcerer does have interesting posts, though. He has set himself an ambitious goal, to come up with something new every week. I wouldn’t object if he reduced the frequency to, say, a couple of times a month, to collect his thoughts so as not to be repetitious.
LikeLiked by 2 people
I was too harsh. Sorcerer has a good site.
It’s very hard to come up with fresh ideas once you’ve said what needs to be said about our overshoot predicament.
Un-Denial no longer features many essays by me and instead has become a place for a few rare like-minded people to hang out, and a vehicle for me and others to chronicle events as they unfold via comments.
I also like to do what I can to amplify good works and good ideas by others in this space.
LikeLiked by 2 people
It is quite possible that we will start off with a slow collapse, but then at some point, when the feedback loops kick in, the bottom will fall out from under modernity.
LikeLike
Pre-1982 U.S. one-cent coins are 95% copper. There are still plenty in circulation. I’ve got a pile of them. Cheapest way to mine copper –
LikeLike
Hey Stellar! I have found the easiest way to understand this is in physics terms. The economy is a dissipative structure. When dissipative structures are not growing, they are collapsing. A slow speed-of-collapse could be defined as ‘de-growth’. But these are just words ‘collapse’ ‘degrowth’ ‘decline’. The real effect for normal people is their living standards go down, which lowers their happiness and quality of life.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yowser!
We must be getting very very close…
Art Berman has gone full on woo by incorporating quantum this and that into his essays.
https://www.artberman.com/blog/quantum-decision-theory/
LikeLiked by 1 person
Add Chris Martenson to the list! The more time he spends with Evie, the dumber he gets. He was genuinely trying to say Astra Zeneca means ‘road to death’ in Latin. Astra means star lol. Mort means death. This is basic educated person stuff we’re dealing with here. LMAO he has gone the full pothead makes a conspiracy video on YouTube.
LikeLiked by 2 people
LOL! I seriously can’t watch any Martenson episode that includes his spouse. They’re so bad.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It personally really irks me that he doesn’t know the difference between data and evidence haha
LikeLike
Damn you monk. You’ve made it so my world doesn’t make sense anymore… I’ve been quoting that Tombstone line my whole life… “How I really hate him”
Assumed that picture was a typo. But I just saw it again and its nagging at me. So I looked it up. Yep, it’s ‘now’. The actual movie script as well as the dvd subtitles… but they’re all wrong goddammit!! Val Kilmer is 100% saying ‘how’. Lips and voice.
I know it still works and makes sense, but the quote is ruined with ‘now’. Might spend rest of my life crusading to get this corrected.😊
If you have any interest, it’s at around the 2:15 mark.
https://youtu.be/GGNdnlCbfMs?t=130
LikeLiked by 1 person
He definitely says “how”! I have watched this movie so many times. It is a childhood favourite. They just don’t make movies this good anymore 😦
LikeLike
Thanks for confirming. Maybe I can get on with my life now.😊
Ya, such a classic. It’s weird though… the actors playing the Earp brothers, Kurt Russell, Bill Paxton, and Sam Elliott… I’m a huge fan of all three but I don’t like any of them in this. You’d think that would hurt the movie big time. But no, it’s all about the bad guys for me. Ringo, Curly Bill, and Ike. (and of course Doc Holliday who steals every scene)
LikeLike
I think they are all amazing and I love Kurt’s moustache. The only bummer in the movie is they don’t reload their pistols after 6 shots. Like when Ringo gets drunk and shoots like 30 rounds out of two handguns … ok movie sure. The outfits in the movie are incredible 🙂 love love love
Doc Holiday is incredible. Maybe I’ll need to re-watch it this weekend LOL
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m embarrassed to say I have Tombstone in my library but have not yet watched it. I’ll bump it higher in the queue.
LikeLike
It is very 90s, but so good
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hey, careful now. Nothing wrong with the 90’s. I did my best work then.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I love the 90s! I was only a kid, but man what a time to be alive 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
I was a completely different person. I knew nothing about the world or overshoot. I was confident, competent, and competitive. My goal was to be a millionaire. I looked down on people who worried about the social issues or environmental damage. My favorite slogan was “Nuke the gay whales for Jesus”.
LikeLiked by 2 people
A Mandela effect?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hmmm i dont think Art is doing anything woo here. I think he is just being metaphorical.
LikeLike
Metaphorical is woo for an engineer. 🙂
If he has something important to say, he should say it clearly without obfuscation or adding some quantum whatever for mystique.
LikeLiked by 1 person
You have spotted that geologists are probably not very good at using literary devices. So you are in fact an excellent writing critic!
LikeLiked by 1 person